The Oceanic 6, Desmond, Penny and Frank settle on 'The Lie'

The first thing we see in the second hour of season 5, "The Lie," is Frank carrying a couple of Jekyll Island beers. Apparently the same beer was seen in an episode of Dexter as well, but the beer doesn't actually exist.

The Oceanic 6 along with Desmond, Penny and Frank discuss the lie that they will tell when they get back. Hurley is the only one who doesn't want to lie, but he goes along with the others. The tension between Hurley and the others, especially Sayid, is a bit strange considering how happy they all were when they got off the plane in Hawaii as well as at Hurley's birthday party.